The cooks at Dave's really put their heart and soul into their dishes. The lobster (generally caught that morning) is very flavorful and plentiful.
The dining area is small and a little dark, and the loitering is a bit of a turn off but the food really makes up for it big time.

Hidden location: Located by the pier in Ocho Rios, next door to Island Village (just a few feet away westward). You'll have to walk or drive down a steep hill before you see Dave's Lobster Delight straight in front of you.